Small, Good Things: Easy as Pie

By Joe Dizney

Pie — food cooked in flour-water paste or dough — has been around since the beginning of civilization. The earliest Greek and Egyptian examples were hand-fashioned containers in which meat was cooked, ostensibly sealing in the juices and flavor.

The Brits unappetizingly celebrated this feature by referring to their earliest emblematic meat pies as coffyns (coffins). This was the precursor to en croute (“in crust”) cooking, a technique brought to its cultured apotheosis by the French.

But truth be told, the pie was initially a crude culinary kluge, as much a practical solution to the absence of kitchenware as anything we would recognize as a recipe. Pie dough was little more than the material from which these makeshift casseroles or desserts got cooked in a time of few or no baking pans. Pie-making served equally well for cooking, storing and transporting.

That’s to say pie — or rather, pie crust — was less a recipe than a technique, used widely and unceremoniously, for cooking what-have-you, savory or sweet. The process was perfunctory, casual and rustic: the crust was most likely not even meant to be eaten, and a far cry from the precious and peculiar recipes that intimidate the contemporary (well, at least this particular) home cook.

Salted Honey Pie, and crust (Photo by J. Dizney)

There are people, however, who make the magical formula look preternaturally easy, and my friend Susan is one of those people. She can knock out a perfect pastry and rustic tart — mixing bowl to oven — in what seems like five minutes, without breaking a sweat and hardly measuring things.

Anticipating the sweet season of fruits and berries, the season most identified with the classic and archetypal “pie,” I consulted the master.

Susan’s recipe is a mere five ingredients: flour and water, sugar, salt and butter. The operative words and instructions for mastery are “cold” and “fast” — everything must be kept cold (including the flour, which she keeps in the refrigerator, and the water, which is iced). If the butter gets too soft, a trip to the fridge is in order. Work fast and loose by hand and with little ceremony for a light, flaky crust.

Susan specifies organic, unbleached all-purpose flour (Bob’s Red Mill is her go-to) and high-fat, unsalted European-style butter (Kerrygold, Plugras). The dough must rest, refrigerated, between mixing and rolling it out to allow glutens a chance to “relax,” making for more elasticity and avoiding breakage. The prepared dough is rolled out as quickly as possible and chilled once again in the pie pan before ultimately being baked.

Her recipe is easily doubled for a two-crust pie, or the mixed and wrapped unformed dough can be frozen for convenience.

Salted Honey Pie (Photo by J. Dizney)

Since local fruit is a mere gleam in the eye at present, I sought some other sweet filling to test Susan’s master crust and came across an intriguing salted honey pie on chef David Lebovitz’s blog (davidlebovitz.com).

Beyond the Beatles’ musical reference, it actually harkens back to ur-recipes for sweet pies which generally used honey as a sweetener. A quick web search uncovered a rich vein of variations, mostly based on a pie from Brooklyn’s Four & Twenty Blackbirds bakery, but the filling in most is basically a simple and not-too-sweet custard (this one uses buttermilk, but whole milk or cream were referenced as was a dairy- or at least lactose-free version). The baked and cooled pie is finally tweaked with a finishing sprinkle of flaky sea salt — Maldon is perfect. Don’t use kosher or any other commercial boxed salts.

The crust for this variation is pre- (or blind-) baked, which is a bit more energy- and time-intensive. But on the whole it’s still just as easy as pie.

Salted Honey Pie

For one 9-inch pie; serves 8

Susan’s Foolproof Crust

7 to 8 tablespoons unsalted butter (high fat European-style)
1 cup organic unbleached all-purpose flour
1 scant tablespoon sugar
¼ teaspoon salt
¼ cup ice water (or a bit more)

  1. Cut butter into dry ingredients with a pastry cutter until pebbly (the consistency of coarse meal). Add water a little at a time and stir with a fork or your fingers just until a slightly sticky dough forms and holds together. Form into a puck shape, wrap in plastic wrap and refrigerate for an hour, or up to 24.
  2. Preheat oven to 350 degrees. Remove dough from fridge, unwrap onto a floured working surface. Whack it a few times to flatten it and let sit for about 10 minutes to soften. Flour a rolling pin and slowly roll dough out to about a 13-inch circle.
  3. Carefully lift an edge of the pastry onto a floured rolling pin and roll the rest of it loosely around the pin. Reverse the process over a 9-inch pie pan, unrolling the dough over the pan, making sure you have even overhang all around. Trim edge or fold and crimp the excess under itself. Gently press dough to the bottom of pan and prick with the tines of a fork. Chill for 30 minutes.
  4. Blind baking: Line bottom of chilled pie shell with parchment or foil and weigh down with dried beans or pie weights. Bake for 15 minutes, then remove briefly from the oven and get rid of the parchment/foil and beans/weights. Cover edge with a crust shield (or create one by gently covering just the edges with foil). Return pan to oven and bake for another 10 minutes. Remove from the oven and cool on a rack while you prepare the filling.

Honey Pie Filling

4 whole eggs (at room temperature)
1¼ cup buttermilk
1 teaspoon vanilla extract
¼ teaspoon freshly grated nutmeg
¾ cup wildflower honey (warmed slightly)
3 tablespoons melted butter
3 tablespoons flour

  1. In a medium bowl, whisk together eggs, buttermilk and vanilla extract till smooth. Add nutmeg and whisk to incorporate. In another bowl, whisk honey and melted butter and slowly stream this mixture into the egg-buttermilk bowl, whisking constantly to incorporate. When blended and lump-free, sift flour into the custard, whisking to incorporate. Cool and strain mixture into cooled pie shell.
  2. Cover edge with a shield or foil. Place pie on a baking sheet on bottom rack of preheated oven. Bake for 30 to 45 minutes until custard sets. Cool to room temperature before serving or keep in fridge for up to two days. Top each slice with a dollop of whipped cream if desired.