Power Pact Threatened

Electricity provider may want out of contract

The company that administers a program under which Beacon, Cold Spring and Philipstown buy electricity at a fixed cost for residents claims that the Brooklyn firm contracted to supply that energy wants to shift customers back to Central Hudson. 

In an April 26 filing with the state Public Service Commission, Joule Assets alleges that Columbia Utilities has notified the agency that it wants to terminate its agreement to supply electricity for Hudson Valley Community Power. However, the copy of the notice released to Joule is completely redacted, except for the Columbia Utilities letterhead, making it impossible to confirm what it says.


The redacted report received by Joule

The energy program is a consortium of Beacon, Cold Spring, Philipstown and seven other municipalities that agreed last year to purchase electricity from renewable sources at 6.6 cents per kilowatt-hour for residents and 7.1 cents for small businesses through June 30, 2024. It was expected the program would save residents money if costs rose and also protect them from the uncertainty of price swings. 

Residents and businesses are automatically enrolled but can opt-out and continue to receive electricity from Central Hudson. Those in the program pay Columbia Utilities for the electricity they use and Central Hudson for delivery, with all the charges appearing on a single bill from Central Hudson.

According to Joule, the agreement saved about 25,000 residents in the 10 municipalities $5.7 million through the first three months of 2022. While they were paying 6.6 cents per kilowatt, the price charged by Central Hudson rose to more than 20 cents per kilowatt-hour in February before dropping to 6 cents as of Wednesday (May 11). 

Chris White, Beacon’s administrator, said the city is in regular communication with Joule and “we fully support Joule’s efforts to ensure Columbia Utilities honors its contractual obligations, including to Beacon customers.”

Jason Angell, who before winning a seat on Philipstown’s Town Board was part of a team that helped put together Hudson Valley Community Power, said he is angry. 

“You shake hands, you make a contract, that contract is good,” said Angell. “You don’t get to just back out of it all of a sudden midway through because it’s a good deal for one side.”

In its filing with the Public Service Commission, which regulates utilities, Joule said it received a letter from Columbia Utilities on Feb. 8 alleging that Central Hudson’s well-documented billing problems were “negatively impacting” Columbia’s efforts to provide service. The company “raised the possibility” of suspending service until the billing problems were resolved, and asserted in a follow-up on March 4 that it had grounds to terminate the agreement, according to Joule. 

Central Hudson’s billing issues are the subject of a state investigation, but, according to Joule, “upon information and belief, based on discussions with Central Hudson,” they have been resolved.

In addition to asking the Public Service Commission to reject any attempt to end the agreement, Joule is calling for the agency to reveal the contents of the April 19 notice it received from Columbia. 

The notice was redacted at Columbia’s request. The firm said it contains trade secrets and confidential information that, if disclosed, “would likely cause substantial injury to the positions of Columbia.” 

Christina Costa, the regulatory affairs manager at Columbia who made the request to the PSC to censor the document, did not respond to an email with questions about its agreement with Hudson Valley Community Power. 

Stephen Filler, Joule’s general counsel and senior vice president, called the redaction an attempt to “to hide an apparent breach of Columbia’s contractual obligations,” adding that “there is no explanation how Columbia would be harmed” by disclosure.

3 thoughts on “Power Pact Threatened

  1. Never liked this deal from the beginning. I especially disliked when my home and business were automatically enrolled by the town and village. Then we had to opt out several times. The supplier claimed that all power would come from green sources. I can’t see how that’s possible, since it’s all the same grid. As far as I can see the company that managed it was out solely for profit under the guise of saving the earth and customers money. Too bad those in charge were duped by them. Let’s just chalk this off as a learning lesson. Forgive them and move on.

  2. The current political climate in America has become so ideologically hardened that people will make decisions that work against their self-interests. A case in point is the negative commentary about the Philipstown Community Choice Aggregation program. This program was instituted in Philipstown to save residents money on their utility bills while trying to slow man made climate change through the use of renewably sourced electricity.

    The facts are that people enrolled in the program continue to save thousands of dollars on their utility bills annually, while combatting global warming; an existential problem that threatens the entire planet. Putting flawed ideological beliefs before the health of the environment, our children and ones own best interests defies logic. I require no forgiveness for taking a stance on behalf of our planet and the people who inhabit it.

  3. I am furious that Columbia Utilities is trying to pull out of the contract that still has more than 2 years left on it. Twenty-five thousand residents in 10 communities have been saving money and getting it from renewable energy. But I guess that’s just it right? We collectively saved $5.7 million in the first few months of this year, and now all of a sudden our agreement isn’t good anymore? If Columbia Utilities won’t honor its end of the deal, it should be very expensive for them to back out of it. This type of greed should not be tolerated. And the Public Service Commission should investigate them.

    If they succeed in terminating our Community Choice Aggregation agreement, we will go back to paying Central Hudson’s rates. I am not looking forward to paying 20 cents per kwh. Share your anger with Columbia Utilities and email [email protected] or call their customer service at 877-726-5862.